Inconvenient Overindulgence: MONBIOT on Green Consumerism 27 July 2007
Thanks to Gail, whose political blog (LINK) is amazing.
Hopefully, you’ve already picked up Monbiot’s book, “HEAT: How to Stop the Planet Burning” (LINK) as it may well be the very best climate change-related text out there, in terms of showing exactly what we can to do make 90% reductions in the next 30 years. I challenge you to find someone else who presents actual solutions.
In Monbiot’s latest post, he details once again a concept I’ve been trying to get across for a long time: We must STOP BUYING SHIT. Instead, we tell ourselves it’s okay to consume like mad, so long as the product is ‘green’. Do you agree? No?
LINK TO MONBIOT’S SITE
Eco-junk
Posted July 24, 2007
GREEN CONSUMERISM WILL NOT SAVE THE BIOSPHERE
By George Monbiot. Published in the Guardian 24th July 2007
It wasn’t meant to happen like this. The climate scientists told us that our winters would become wetter and our summers drier. So I can’t claim that these floods were caused by climate change, or are even consistent with the models. But, like the ghost of Christmas yet to come, they offer us a glimpse of the possible winter world we’ll inhabit if we don’t sort ourselves out.
With rising sea levels and more winter rain (and remember that when the trees are dormant and the soils saturated there are fewer places for the rain to go) all it will take is a freshwater flood to coincide with a high spring tide and we have a formula for full-blown disaster. We have now seen how localised floods can wipe out essential services and overwhelm emergency workers. But this month’s events don’t even register beside some of the predictions now circulating in learned journals(1). Our primary political struggle must be to prevent the break-up of the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets. The only question now worth asking about climate change is how.
Dozens of new books appear to provide an answer: we can save the world by embracing “better, greener lifestylesâ€. Last week, for example, the Guardian published an extract of the new book by Sheherazade Goldsmith, who is married to the very rich environmentalist Zac, in which she teaches us “to live within nature’s limitsâ€(2). It’s easy: just make your own bread, butter, cheese, jam, chutneys and pickles, keep a milking cow, a few pigs, goats, geese, ducks, chickens, beehives, gardens and orchards. Well, what are you waiting for?
Her book also contains plenty of useful advice, and she comes across as modest, sincere and well-informed. But of lobbying for political change, there is not a word: you can save the planet in your own kitchen – if you have endless time and plenty of land. When I was reading it on the train, another passenger asked me if he could take a look. He flicked through it for a moment then summed up the problem in seven words. “This is for people who don’t work.â€
None of this would matter, if the Guardian hadn’t put her photo on the masthead last week, with the promise that she could teach us to go green. The media’s obsession with beauty, wealth and fame blights every issue it touches, but none more so than green politics. There is an inherent conflict between the aspirational lifestyle journalism which makes readers feel better about themselves and sells country kitchens and the central demand of environmentalism: that we should consume less. “None of these changes represents a sacrificeâ€, Sheherazade tells us. “Being more conscientious isn’t about giving up things.†But it is: if, like her, you own more than one home when others have none.
Uncomfortable as this is for both the media and its advertisers, giving things up is an essential component of going green. A section on ethical shopping in Goldsmith’s book advises us to buy organic, buy seasonal, buy local, buy sustainable, buy recycled. But it says nothing about buying less.
Green consumerism is becoming a pox on the planet. (more…)

Not my typical fare (for this blog, at least), but as this article isn’t getting enough press in the U.S., I feel compelled to point you to it, dearest reader, lest you’ve not paid attention lately to the horrific disease that may well claim a number of those close to you:
CONSERVING AND REBUILDING SOILS